BOOK FREE CONSULTATION
Home Results Luigi Training Blog Contact Free Workout Book a free consultation
← All posts

Training

Walking vs running for weight loss: which actually works better?

Someone decides it's time to lose a few pounds and has to choose: walk every day, or force themselves to start running. The internet gives both answers, usually with a lot of confidence. So here's walking vs running for weight loss, without the confidence: what each one actually burns, what the trials show they do to body fat, and the catch nobody mentions until your shins hurt.

One thing before we start, because it changes how you read everything else: this post is about cardio against cardio. If you're weighing cardio against lifting, I've covered that in cardio or weights for fat loss.

Per mile, running burns more — but not as much more as you'd think

The old line is that "a mile is a mile": walk it or run it, you burn the same. It's not quite true. In a lab study, 24 people walked and ran the same 1,600 metres while their energy use was measured[1]. Running the distance used about 480 kJ (roughly 115 kcal), walking it about 340 kJ (roughly 80 kcal). So running burned around 40% more for the same distance.

The bigger difference is time. The runners covered the distance in half the time, so per minute running burned close to three times as much. That's the real argument for running: not that it's magic, but that it does more in the time you've got. It was one small study at set speeds, so treat the exact figures as a ballpark rather than your personal numbers.

What the trials say about cardio and weight loss

Here's the part that rarely makes it into the headlines. A meta-analysis of 14 randomised trials gave overweight adults aerobic exercise on its own, without changing their diet, for six to twelve months[2]. The average weight loss was about 1.6–1.7 kg. The authors' blunt conclusion was that cardio on its own is not an effective weight-loss treatment, though it may help alongside changes to diet.

Walking on its own tells a similar story. A meta-analysis of 32 randomised trials in previously inactive people found walking reduced weight by about 1.4 kg, body fat by about 1.2 percentage points and waist size by about 1.5 cm[3]. It also lowered blood pressure and improved fitness. So walking clearly does something — it's just not a fast route to weight loss by itself.

That's the honest frame for the whole walking vs running question: either one helps, neither one replaces what you eat.

Is running better over the long run?

There's some evidence it might be. A large survey followed about 15,000 walkers and 32,000 runners for just over six years[4]. For the same estimated energy spent, running was linked to more weight loss than walking, especially in heavier people.

Caveats, and they're big ones. It's observational, so it shows a link, not proof. The exercise was self-reported. The runners were already lighter and doing more at the start. And it's a single author's analysis of one dataset. I'd take it as "running may have a slight edge", not "walking doesn't work".

On intensity, a meta-analysis of 13 trials in overweight adults compared interval training with steady moderate exercise[5]. Fat loss was similar, but intervals took about 40% less time. Running-based programmes showed large effects on fat mass whichever style was used, while cycling programmes didn't produce fat loss in those trials. They were short trials, averaging ten weeks, so I wouldn't build a theory on the cycling result. But it fits the idea that weight-bearing cardio pulls its weight.

The catch: running is where people get hurt

This is the bit people find out the hard way. A meta-analysis of running injury studies found novice runners had about 17.8 injuries per 1,000 hours of running, against 7.7 for regular recreational runners[6]. Put another way, a new runner averages roughly one injury for every 56 hours of running. The studies defined "injury" in different ways, so the exact numbers are rough, but the pattern is clear: the first months are the risky ones.

My read on why, from coaching rather than from these studies: enthusiasm builds faster than tendons do. People feel fitter after a few weeks and add distance, speed and extra runs all at once, before their legs have caught up.

That matters for weight loss, because an injury doesn't just stop the running. It usually stops everything for a few weeks. The best cardio for fat loss is the one you can keep doing, week after week, without breaking down.

What I actually tell clients

A plan for fat loss that you can actually keep up. If you're looking for a personal trainer near Streatham, start with a free, no-obligation consultation — I'm at Anytime Fitness Tulse Hill, a short trip from Streatham, coaching from 5am, seven days a week.

Book a free consultation →

References

  1. Hall C, Figueroa A, Fernhall B, Kanaley JA. Energy expenditure of walking and running: comparison with prediction equations. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2004;36(12):2128–2134. PubMed
  2. Thorogood A, Mottillo S, Shimony A, et al. Isolated aerobic exercise and weight loss: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Am J Med. 2011;124(8):747–755. PubMed
  3. Murtagh EM, Nichols L, Mohammed MA, Holder R, Nevill AM, Murphy MH. The effect of walking on risk factors for cardiovascular disease: an updated systematic review and meta-analysis of randomised control trials. Prev Med. 2015;72:34–43. PubMed
  4. Williams PT. Greater weight loss from running than walking during a 6.2-yr prospective follow-up. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2013;45(4):706–713. PubMed
  5. Wewege M, van den Berg R, Ward RE, Keech A. The effects of high-intensity interval training vs. moderate-intensity continuous training on body composition in overweight and obese adults: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Obes Rev. 2017;18(6):635–646. PubMed
  6. Videbæk S, Bueno AM, Nielsen RO, Rasmussen S. Incidence of running-related injuries per 1000 h of running in different types of runners: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Sports Med. 2015;45(7):1017–1026. PubMed
CALL LUIGI WHATSAPP